Place plum juice, lemon juice, and SureJell in large stainless steel pot and bring to rolling boil over medium high heat stirring constantly.
Once the boil is rolling and you are unable to stir it down boil for 1 minute, then add the sugar. If the sugar balls up use a wooden spoon to press against the side of the pot to break up the ball.
Stir constantly to dissolve sugar, bringing back to a boil. Once boil is rolling again stop stirring and allow to boil for 2 minutes. Jelly will foam up at this point so be sure you've used a pot that is big enough to allow for this.
Turn off heat and add butter which helps to reduce foam. If you do get some foam in your jars of jelly you can remove it with a clean teaspoon before sealing.
Transfer jelly to heated jars filling to just below ring marks. Top with heated lid and seal with ring twisting tightly.
Place jars upside down for approximately 30 minutes which increases heat at the lid and helps seal the jars. Flip so jars are right side up after half hour and allow to cool to room temperature.
Test each jar to see if it has sealed by pressing firmly on the center of the lid. If a jar has sealed there will be no give, if the lid presses up and down then the seal did not take. Store any jars that did not seal in the fridge and use first.
Sealed jars may be kept in a cool dark pantry for up to one year.